Boy am I glad Libertine surprised me with a sample of this. I had only ever tried one other BDK scent (Gris Charnel), which I disliked a lot. Admittedly that was before I started to get clued up on the world of fragrance so I should probably give it another go. Anyway, back to Tabac Rose. I adore this scent! It is such a beautiful combination of rose, chocolate, tobacco and spice. It is warm, so perfect for winter. It has superb projection and longevity. Slight feminine lean I feel, but would absolutely smell amazing on a man. Highly recommend.