I’ve been using this rose water toner for years, it’s my absolute favourite. Comparing this the my previous bottles the formula has been updated. The ingredients remain the same but the order of the ingredients listed (quantity/percentage) of them has changed. Instead of being simply a toner it now acts more like an astringent. Personally I like this change as I have been able to remove witch hazel from my routine as this now does it job as well. For those with oily or acne prone skin this is especially great, I would highly recommend it.